Dettingen

 We've done Dettingen before at the club using Brown Bess, but John wanted to use it as a test bed for his squared version and also as a tryout for his Powerpoint implementation of remote gaming. He'd drawn out the battlefield using multiple layers in PP, created the unit icons using NATO map symbols with suitable annotations and added some game support markers (hits, routed etc). With it being a PP slide, it is pretty easy to move the various objects around and change their orientation.

I can't actually recall who played which side, but I was British (possibly the British infantry?). I've taken photos of the shared computer screen but the are a bit grainy.

For those unfamiliar with the battle, the retreating Allied army (Dutch, British, Austrian) is hemmed in between the River Main and some forested hills, with its route cut by some wicked French in their way defending a tributary of the Main. Fortunately the French commander decided to deploy his army on the wrong side of the stream, (reputedly at the insistence of the Maison du Roi). Anyway, it gave the Allies a fighting chance at least.

The action opened with a massive cavalry charge against the Allied left flank. Fortunately our musketry was fairly decent and the French took several hits prior to contact. The French infantry also pressed forward on our right but seemed to forget the  rather large gap bewteeen them and the forest.

Our cavalry took advantage of this and outflanked them, while our infantry pinned them frontally. Over on the left, our troops were engaged in a prolonged melee with the French cavalry. The initial volleys had given us a  considerable advantage, and the only thing stopping the Maison du Roi routing was the presence of a General.

The French left was soon in fairly dire straits. Over on our left the Maison eventually routed but a fresh French cavalry unit routed the weakened British infantry. Fortunately we had cavalry in reserve.

Our cavalry intervened an annihilated the impudent French horsemen. The entire Allied right now wheeled inwards and began mopping up the French centre.

The French left collapsed, and although they did manage to rout an Allied cavalry unit on their right, things weren't looking too good.

Endgame. The French artillery was overrun and almost every other remaining French unit routed. The Allied army was able to make it escape from the pursuing French force to the south. Hurrah for King George!  

For a first tryout of the grid based set, that all worked fine as the basic mechanissms are well tested. My main observation was that it didn't seem very linear - it was far too easy to manouvre to a flank and wheel, which didn't seem very eighteenth century. This was a feature of the grid based movement movement points, but was easily fixed by more stringent wheeling penalties (on the tabletop it takes an entire turn for a unit in line to wheel 90 degrees due to the geometry of the thing), and John updated the rules to include more restrictive turning for units in line.

Otherwise, it was much the same outcome as last time we played it as the inferior quality of the French infantry puts them at a big disadvantage. The French cavalry are very good though and we were fortunate to have driven them off without suffering heavier losses. I can't imagine what trying to assault a French position on the far side of the stream would be like, very nasty indeed.

Mokra, Poland 1939

 Tim put on another outing with NBC, this time a trip back to Poland in 1939, so we used my WW2 version. This scenario covered the Battle of Mokra which featured 4th Panzer Div attempting to push a an entrenched Polish cavalry brigade out of a forest. Possibly not the best place to employ tanks....

Simon, Pete and I were the wicked Germans, while John, Graham and Jerry took the plucky Poles. This is perhaps the only NBC game where we've managed to deploy and entire Panzer Division, and a 1939 one at that, with a full panzer brigade of two regiments. Oh my!

Sadly the Germans were attacking off the line of march, so their units arrived in dribs and drabs. Still, the enemy were only blokes on horses so I'm sure it will all be fine. I was cast as Reinhardt, notionally Div Commander for this one, so I just allocated areas of operations to 34th and 35th Panzer Regiments (myself and Pete respectively), and our supporting Schutzen Regiment (Simon). We were basically aiming for a breakthrough in the centre, with 34PzR pinning the Poles frontally, 35 PzR skirting the woods to the south and and the Schutzen crashing through the woods to support Pete.

View from the south. Mokre and its surrounding forests is packed with dug in Poles. My 34th PzR visible in the distance. To model the historically disjointed German attacks, Tim had modelled each PzR with three small battalions instead of two big battalions, 34th PzR also had a few hits on it already.

One of my battalions crashed into this enticing gap in the woods. I hadn't realised that two batteries of Polish 75mm guns were positioned further back to cover it with direct fire!

The assault could have gone better and although we inflicted some losses and routed one regiment of Poles, most of my regiment ended up on its start line in a state of disorder, leaving some more burning panzers behind. We'd certainly got their attention though and now 35th PzR was turning up.

The Polish armoured reserves trundled into view. A mixed battalion of tankettes and armoured cars, plus an armoured train!

My chaps rallied and reorganised for another go, while Pete pushed a fresh battalion down the road.

My Panzer IVs hung around shelling the Polish trenches while the Pz Is and IIs sorted themselves out. The 75mm direct fire HE was surprisingly effective (or lucky).

While I kept the Poles busy, the rest of Petes Regiment rolled on in a big column down the road, in somewhat better shape than my chaps.

Unfortunately his lead battalion took some hits from the guns in the train and fell back in disorder,

This was followed up by an impudent attack by the Polish armour! The Poles managed to obliterate the disorganised Germans.

Intervention by Stukas didn't see them off.

And it took another Panzer battalion to engage them.

Who duly assaulted them and the handful of Polish survivors broke and fell back, down to platoon strength.

My guys attacked the gap again as fresh Polish troops moved up, but once more suffered heavy losses even though one Polish unit was routed.

My survivors fell back again, while Pete charged the remains of the Polish armour (bottom right corner).

The Germans were victorious, but again at heavy cost. This battalion was reduced to half a stand. By now the Schutzen units were starting to appear.

A great big mass of German units was forming up around the road while the Poles sorted their defences out. If only we'd had all this stuff to start with!

The Schutzen battalions attacked on foot against the two southern woods hexes. Mark IV companies provided fire support from each flank (the divisional artillery was still way back down the road).

Desperate fighting took place over the trenches, as the Poles grimly hung on. The battered panzers had sorted themselves out now, 35th PzR started to move up and 34th PzR reorganised itself into a single composite battalion, led my by my personal command stand.

One of the German rifle battalions fell back in disorder, but the other bludgeoned its way into the Polish trenches. Stukas meanwhile softened up the defenders of the gap in front of 34th PzR.

The victorious German infantry pressed on and attacked the second Polish regiment to its south east.

They manged to defeat the second Polish regiment, but in turn suffered such heavy losses that they also broke and fell back. The woods south of Mokre were now clear of enemy though, including the annoying AT position which had shot up 34th PzR repeatedly.

While all this excitement was going on, one of Petes battalions assaulted the armoured train, whose ability to evade was a bit limited. Although the train inflicted some losses, the panzers shot it up at close range and it was disabled.

The Polish southern flank had pretty much collapsed by now and the way was open towards Warsaw.

The final act was for 34th PzR to assault the gap for a third time and this time they succeeded in defeating the defenders and setting themselves up to overrun the Polish gun line. With that we called it a day, the Germans had managed to break through and seriously damaged the defenders, but at hideous cost to themselves, losing 150 tanks in the process. Funnily enough, the Poles claimed 150 tanks in the original battle, and Polish cavalry were well tooled up with heavy anti-tank rifles which could make mincemeat of all the early panzers, most of which were only bullet proof.

That was a good game covering an interesting historical battle. NBC worked fine once more, and having larger units and an number of HQs allowed the players to cycle their units between reorganising and the front. The Poles acquitted themselves well and it was touch and go for the Germans all the way through. irl 4th Panzer discovered that unsupported tanks don't work too well in forests, and a few days later (having repaired many of their losses) they also discovered they don't work too well in cities as they attacked Warsaw. None of this shambles seemed to affect Reinhardts career, as he was given a full Panzer Corps in France and ended up commanding an entire Army Group in 1944.

 

3D Printing

In a break from our usual remote games, Pete gave us a talk and demo of his 3D printing setup. It is one of those technologies which has come on in leaps and bounds in recent years. My first exposure to it was a few years ago in the Medical School at work where 3D printers were being used to synthesise replacement bone sections for maxillofacial surgery, and the process involved 3D scanning to generate the shapes of the pieces. I was later fortunate enough to visit the Advanced Manufacturing Research Centre where components of the Boeing 787 were being manufactured using a 3D printer which cost around a million pounds. Perhaps a bit out of reach of the hobbyist!

So, it hasn't been something I've paid much attention to, but increasingly I've seen things that people had produced in the wargaming community, which are good quality and relatively inexpensive. Last year Pete bought a 3D printer which makes plastic models, and he ran us through the sorts of things he'd done.

The main thing which make this all work is the control/slicing software, which in this case was provided with the printer.

Here a 3D model has been loaded into the slicing software. The software controls scaling, how many models to produce in each print run and critical variables around material thickness and density, the resolution of the 3D image and whether some of the extrusions (MG barrels etc) need additional support while printing.

The model above is of a WW1 Mark IV tank.

And this is the finished thing. It even has air gaps under the unditching beam rails, just amazing. The thing which really surprised me was the number of 3D models available for free. The Mark IV model came from a free pack containing virtually every WW1 AFV ever made, and which could be scaled up or down as required.

I'd always imagined being crouched over a 3D CAD programme trying to draw a Tiger tank in 3D, but it looks like for many subjects,. other people have already done the hard work.

Petes printer runs off plastic filament, which is about £18 for a kilo of material. The other main type of home printer uses resin which has the huge advantage that it can print multiple models simultaneously. With a plastic printer, the print time scales in proportion to the amount of material used so more models take longer. Resin is more expensive (around £40 a kilo) and harder to work with though.

The business end is here, the heated printer head, which moves over the print base. The process is hot, slow, noisy and smelly, so finding somewhere sensible to run the printer is a must.

But the finished results are great. A trio of 15mm Schneiders, virtually unobtainable as decent models in this scale except at vast cost.

That was a really interesting session. I'm at the stage where I have more stuff than I know what to do with, and the limitation is one of storage space, so I'm not convinced either the capital cost or the effort of learning how to do it is worthwhile for my situation. If you did need to run off one, or a ton, of specific vehicles, guns, figures or terrain pieces, then it is ideal though. 

This is already a viable alternative to traditional manufacturers, and even if the DIY aspect doesn't appeal to everyone, one can imagine a future where figures are printed on demand, in much the same way as books are on Lulu.

  

One Glorious Morning. AWI OHW

 Simon put on an American War of Independance game using a grid based version of One Hour Wargames. I was interested to see how this worked as the bases I've adopted for my WW2 variant are so huge they may as well be grid areas!

I did an early hex version for WW2 but that used a 9x9 grid, whereas Simon went for the very bold approach of using a 6x6 grid.

The British forces were myself (with two line regiments), Graham (with two regiments of Hessians) and Tim G with a regiment each of Light Infantry and Scottish Infantry. The Scots were classed as shock troops and had a morale and melee bonus.

The wicked Rebs were John with two units of rifle armed frontier types, and Tim C with two regiments of continental infantry.  

The scenario was based on one in the OHW book, itself based on an AiW counter insurgency sweep against the 'Swamp Fox'. Tim Cs general was the Swan Fox himself.

Apologies for the poor quality pics, it is how things came out on the monitor. The table from the south. The river is only crossable at the fords the woods are dense and marshy, so our chaps can't go in them. 

Simon used a card activation system for units (so it wasn't IGOUGO like the standard rules). The first unit on was my General figure up in the top right corner.

As time progressed the protagonists all appeared. The Rebels had very unfairly put their riflemen in the 'impassable' woods, so all our chaps could do was stand outside and shoot at them.

Our basic plan was simple. The Hessians would advance south west and take the village via the centre ford to pin the enemy. The Scots would go left flanking and the English regulars would be in reserve to exploit.

The Hessians quickly got engaged in a prolonged firefight with the Rebels and in the image above the Scots infantry are about the assault the right hand ford defended by some Continentals. I have committed one reserve regiment to help to Hessians clear the woods at B3.

The Scots and Continentals duly wiped each other out! This left the ford uncovered as the riflemen were pinned in firefights, and the Lights hastened towards it. Tim C was hideously unlucky trying to activate his reserve Continentals and they were stuck south of the village. Along with the card draws for sequence, units needed to throw a Blitzkrieg Commander style activation throw with various modifiers.

The British lights masked the rebel riflemen in D4 while we continued to plaster B3 with massed volleys. Despite their cover, we were inflicting hits. The game had the novel concept that cover let units take extra hits, but they lost the benefit if they moved out, so it was possible for units to become completely pinned in cover - which is what happened here.

I personally led the reserve British regiment across the ford. Unfortunately one of the Hessians had enough and ran off.

I galloped back to supervise the defeat of the rebels in B3, which freed up the other Hessians to take on the last riflemen. The British were well across the ford and formed up in a neat line, as the Continentals marched cautiously towards them. Having a General nearby gave an activation bonus, so commander placement was fairly important.

The last riflemen were despatched and both regiments of British pushed forward on each flank. The 'swamp fox' pulled his last unit back into a wood near our exit point.

The entire British army surged forward (apart from the Lights who failed their activation roll). The Rebels decided discretion was the better part of valour and melted away. A glorious British victory!

Eagle eyed readers will have noticed that the figures are rather....flat. That is because they are paper cutouts, and very pretty they are indeed. Here are a couple of closeups of the units.

That all went pretty well and it has inspired me to revisit my own OHW variants. I'd already done a hex based WW2 version and it shouldn't be beyond the bounds of human ingenuity to convert my latest WW2 offering to a grid. I am wondering about using squares instead of hexes though, as on such a small table, the hex grid distortion is quite marked and leads, at the most basic, to obvious issues with two units being able to gang up on one automatically, which doesn't seem quite right. Squares solve this as units can only ever be adjacent to one other orthogonally, even though squares have some other issues.

Panzers on Parade!

This is a bit of a response to the challenge posed by Chris K on his NQM blog, and taken up by Archduke Piccolo. Matching the ratios of vehicle types in our fleets of toys to the ratios of real world holdings of the Panzerwaffe.

https://notquitemechanised.wordpress.com/2020/06/11/a-proportionate-view-of-german-armour-2/

http://archdukepiccolo.blogspot.com/2020/06/armoured-inventory-ww2-german.html

Chris had looked at overall wartime production of vehicle types, divided by 600 to generate the comparison figures. I chose to focus on my 15mm tank fleet, as I have so many in 6mm it would be hard to count them all, while my 20mm collection is fairly small and curated.

So looking at overall production, it is something like this. Figures for real world production are in hundreds, whereas 'my fleet' is individual vehicles!

Model (total Production)	43	War	Toys	Notes
Pz I	0	16	8	Incl 1 x PzBfl
Pz II	0.5	18	5	(plus 4 unbuilt)
Wespe	5	6	1
Marder II	4.5	7	0
All Pz I/II chassis	10	45	14
Pz 38(t)	1	14	6
Marder III	10	12	2
Grille	2	5	1
Hetzer	0	30	0	So many!
All 38(t) chassis	13	64	9
Pz III A-H	1	29	5	Plus one unbuilt
Pz III J2-N	16	27	3
Stug A-E	0.5	8	2
Stug F-G	33.5	55	6
StuH 42	2	12	1
All Pz III chassis	53	132	17
Pz IV A-F1	0.5	9	2	Plus two unbuilt
Pz IV F2-J	34.5	74	9
Stug IV	10	11	0	I use stugs
JagdPz IV	15	19	2	Plus 2 x 20mm
Sturm Pz IV	2.5	3	1
Hornisse/Hummel	7	12	0
Pz IV AA	2	3	1
All Pz IV chassis	71.5	131	15
Pz V	18	58	11	Incl 4 x Corgi
JagdPz V	2	4	2
All Pz V chassis	20	62	13
Tiger I	6.5	13	3
SturmTiger	0	2	0
Tiger II	0	5	4	1 x Porsche
JagdTiger	0	1	1
Ferdinand	1	1	2
All Tigers	7.5	22	10

I have to say I'm not convinced by war production as a metric as the operational consumption of vehicles rose so sharply in the war. In 1944/45 German AFV production was at its highest ever level, but so was its loss rate. The production figures for Pz 1 look a bit low here too.

Another metric to consider is actual inventory at a point in time ie stock of tanks to hand as a comparator of sensible vehicle ratios. Fortunately Jentz saves us the bother of trying to work this stuff out. I struggled to find comparable inventories for SP guns, I did find some for Stugs, which will have to do.

Tank inventory at June of the specified year (hundreds)

Model	39	40	41	42	43	44	45	My fleet
Pz I	14	10	9	7	-	-	-	8
Pz II	12	9	10	8	3	4	-	4
Pz III (37)	1	3	4	1				0*
Pz III (50,75)	0	0	10	23	14	8	5	8
Pz IV	2	2	5	7	12	23	15	11
PzV	0	0	0	0	3	20	21	11
Tiger I	-	-	-	(1)	2	7	2	3
Tiger II	-	-	-	-	-	(1)	2	4
Pz 35	2	1	2	-	-	-	-	0**
Pz 38	1	3	8	5	2	2	-	6
Stug III/IV					18	28	18	9

*I cheat and use Pz IIIG as Pz IIIe
**I cheat and use Pz38s

I think this gives a much better idea of vehicle ratios. The real standouts for me are the vast numbers of Panzer I right into 1942, the small numbers of Pz IV until 1944 and the large number of Panthers in 44/45. Some vehicle types are over-represented in my collection (esp Tigers) and others under-presetned (SP artillery, Marders) but by and large I was collecting vehicles with a view to one stand = one platoon type games and the mix more reflects company and battalion organisations at particualr points of the war than anything else. I am a bit light on Pz IIs for the 1939-40 period, but that is why I have four unbuilt.

Anyway, enough tables, lets have some pictures.

Here are my Pz Is. A mix of QRF and SDD. The one at the front is sporting Nationalist colours for the Spanish Civil War. I have actually used these a fair bit in various early war and SCW games. They are fairly under represented in other scales, the only 6mm ones I've got are command vehicles, but I do have a few Jagdpanzer 1s.

On an early war theme, here are my various Pz 38s. Half a dozen Zvezda 38ts, fairly plain so they'll do for German, Rumanian and Slovak. I've also got a couple of BF Marders and a QRF (or maybe BF?) Grille. I've also got  moderate numbers of these in 6mm, as well as various Marders and other SP guns including Hetzers.

I don't have any Pz 35s, although I do have a fair number in 6mm in both German and Rumanian service.

Panzer IIs. The tanks are all Peter Pig, and the some of the few survivors from my 15mm desert forces. These were repainted panzer grey and have fought in 1940 France. Handpainted markings, which I'm not sure I could manage now. I also have four Zvezda ones unbuilt, which I must assemble at some point. I have quite a few of these in 6mm, in both panzer grey and desert sand.

I've also got a BF Wespe but no Marders on Pz II chassis. Again, I have a fair number of Pz II SPs in 6mm, including some SP 150mm infantry guns, Marders and Wespe

Early war Pz IIIs. The tanks are all Peter Pig Pz IIIG/H although I use them as IIIe as well. More survivors from the Afrika Korps in different colours. They are supported by a couple of Zvezda Stug IIID, which are lovely little models.

As might be expected I have quite a few of these in 6mm in various colour schemes.

Later war Pz IIIs. I've got a few Pz IIIL (converted from Zvezda flammpanzers) and several Stugs. Good job given the Stug inventory figures. The Stugs are a mixture of PP and PSC with a range of mantlets, various confgurations of side skirts and including one StuH. Being a terrible cheapskate I also use these as Stug IVs and early Jagdpanzer IVs as they all look much the same. 

I am rather more selective in 6mm.

Early war Pz IVs. These are Peter Pig Pz IVD I think. The last of the Afrika Korps. I have a couple of Zvezda ones unbuilt too. The numbers of Pz I, II, III, 38t and IVs I have are able to model various combinations of early war panzer battalions at one stand = one platoon. The 15mm early war tanks have seen more action in 1940 France than anywhere else as I'e mainly been doing the 41-42 eastern front in 6mm. That may change as I've got more 15mm Russian stuff now.

Later war Panzer IVs. I have quite a few of these from various manufacturers. The tanks are BF, PSC and PP, with varying combinations of turret and side skirts. Models range of PzIVG to PzIVJ. There are also a couple of Jagdpanzer IV/70s (QRF, lovely little models) and a BF Brumbar. Essentially there is enough stuff here for a late war panzer battalion at one stand = one platoon, using a Pz III as a command vehicle. The Jagdpanzer IVs are there for the Panzer IV/70 companies in late war tank battalions as well as divisional panzerjaeger battalions. The largest number of these I hacve used was in our game of Periers Ridge which featured half of 22nd Panzer Regiment.

Panthers! Again, I have a fair few of these, enough for a late war panther battalion at one stand = one platoon. Models include D, A and G, manufacturers being PP, Zvezda and some dodgy Corgi diecasts.  There are also a couple of Zvezda Jagdpanthers to serve both in indepedant panzerjager battalions but also the ersatz Panther companies such as the one Panzr Lehr used in the Battle for the Reichswald and also featured in the battles for East Prussia and Silesia. The Germans had a lot of Panthers in the last 12 months of the war. I also have a vague hankering to run Grossdeutschland at Kursk with its brigade of 200(!) Panthers. The most Panthers I used in a game was one of the Sandomierz Bridgehead in 1944 when I used a whole (weak) battalion, as well as the 107th Panzer Brigade at Veghel.

  

Tigers. The Tiger 1s are all Peter Pig, each model is slightly different with various combos of wheels, damage and stowage. Very hefty pieces. Enough for a company (or a battalion at one stand per company), I've had these for some years. The Zvezda Ferdinands are relatively new additions, mainly bought for some occasional Kursk battles, but they would do for Elephants later in the war as well.

I don't have huge numbers of 6mm Tigers, but I do have quite a few Elephants. A second hand purchase which included some oddities. I also don't have a 15mm SturmTiger, but I do have a 20mm one, converted from the Airfix model. I've never used more than three of these at once, and gernally only one or two.

More Tigers! I have quite a few Tiger IIs, partly due to finding a shop selling off a job lot of Roco Henschel turret Tigers. I used to use them to mark unspotted German vehicles, as in 'Pattons Best', and like the Tiger 1s, enough for a company (or a battalion). Later war Tiger Bns were predominantly equipped with these . I picked up the Porsche turret one later, handy for Operation Goodwood, and avid readers may recall its exploits in our Bulge game last year as it assaulted St Vith with all its pals. Finally, there is a Jagdtiger, converted from a TII which I have yet to repaint. Not a very common vehicle, but there was a battalion in the Bulge and they later hung around in the Battle of the Rhineland.

So there we go,  a whistlestop tour of my 15mm German tanks and SPs. I've only been collecting these since the late 90s, so it isn't a bad haul. A lot of my 6mm stuff dates back to the mid 1970s, and there really is an awful lot of that. I think I've got at least 20 Panthers and countless hordes of Pz III and Pz IV.