With a mini "heatwave" upon us in Britain (I am sure my overseas readers will rollaround laughing at our idea of hot) , naturally I was casting around for some winter warfare inspiration to use with my snowy Hexon boards. I thought about re-visiting the Battle for Moscow and I could have sworn I had a few books about it, but the best I could turn up was this one:
The Battle for Moscow by Albert Seaton, first published in 1971! Hardly cutting edge, but I thought it was worth a re-read. It is very much of its time, however Seaton was one of the first people to dig through the German archives rather than rely on the rather unreliable interviews and memoirs of the various German Generals published through the 1950s and 60s. Prior to Seatons books the best we could hope for were Mellenthins 'Panzer Battles', Guderians 'Panzer Leader' and Mansteins 'Lost Victories' etc.
It is still a very German pov, but hopefully more balanced than the memoirs. This isn't actually a bad book, it is well written, probably more readable than John Erickson or even David Glantz and covers the major events well although it is maddeningly vague about actual Russian strengths. It does give formation counts (brigades, divisions) by Army which is good enough for what I need.
Like so many military history books, the maps are sparse and not hugely helpful being very high level. They are also all hand drawn, a symptom of its age, but they give a reasonable idea of where the major formations were and when. I've got a copy of 'Panzergruppe Guderian' so I can always look at that for more detailed maps if needs be.
I was pleasantly surprised and came away with a few ideas for representative actions in the snow which will no doubt appear here in due course.
The first of Seatons books I bought was this one, 'The Russo-German War 1941-45', oddly also published in 1971. Given its age this is one of the best single volume histories of the Eastern Front I've ever read, and it includes neglected subjects like the naval war. It is certainly better than Glantz's 'When Titans Clashed' even if the latter has more up to date research on both the Soviet and German sides.
Given the publication dates, I suspect Battle for Moscow is a sub volume of The Russo German War, they certainly cover a lot of the same ground about the background to Operation Barbarossa etc.
Anyway, Glantz's 'Barbarossa' also has a decent section on the Battle for Moscow, which gives a more Soviet centric view and more importantly, lists some of the formations which made up the various Soviet armies in more detail. Coupled with some snippets from John Ericksons 'Road to Stalingrad' I've got enough to work up a few scenarios with the historical units. I am determined to get my scratch built Soviet 85mm AA guns into action around Tula!
Useful review, thanks.
ReplyDeleteThanks. I'm sure there are much more modern books on this stuff.
DeleteLook forward to seeing where this leads, Martin. I am currently focusing mainly on the Russians in WW2 in my painting, reading and watching (of Russian war films on YouTube!)
ReplyDeleteI got a bit "Russianed out" a few months ago with the series of mid 1943 games. I think we did at least half a dozen, maybe more. But doing the early war WRG games has given me a hankering to get some early grand tactical games going to.. Hopefully it will end up as a three scenario mini campaign, I like doing those as they are manageable.
DeleteI have been pulled back towards reading (or rather listening) to 1941-45 Russian Campaign, looks like I have another author to add to the list. Up to Summer 42 .. then it's a case of you see it coming!
ReplyDeleteThere is just so much going on in Russia in WW2. I find summer 41 can be a bit depressing for the Russians, although we've done a few decent games in the sunshine, but I thought some mud and snow might even things up. If you are only going to dig out one Seaton book, I'd go for The Russo German War, although Glantz covers a lot of this stuff perfectly adequately. I always found Erickson a bit of a slog.
DeleteGood stuff, Martin!
ReplyDeleteJust finished “Meatgrinder” by Prit Buttar (on Rhzev salient) and started Beevor’s “Stalingrad,” so on a Russian Front kick myself.
V/R,
Jack
Excellent! I really like Buttars books, his series of First World War Eastern Front ones are excellent, but I've not looked at his WW2 ones.
Delete