Friday, 20 November 2026

Brandy Station, June 1863

 Despite me saying that Chancellorsville was our last trip to the ACW for a while, here we are again. If I'm going to Gettysberg, I have to do Brandy Station first as it had a critical impact on Gettysberg itself.

So, here we are in June 1863, JEB Stuart has decided to hold a grand review of his cavalry division in the hopes it will be upgraded to a full Corps (with consequent promotions for him and his brigade commanders), and tarried in one spot for several days. Pleasantons Union Cavalry Corps got wind of the Confederate concentration and decided to give them a nasty surprise.

The original scenario is from the Volley and Bayonet ACW scenario book and I'll run the game using my version of Neil Thomas's ACW rules.


Battlefield from the south. The Rappahannock is on the  right, crossed by several fords, Brandy Station is the road/rail junction on the left. Otherwise the country is rolling with open woods and various roads leading around. The railway crossing the centre of the table is the Orange and Alexandria Railroad.


Which is of course an excuse to put my new ACW steam train on the table! As Stuarts cavalry were camped for four days, I'm sure plenty of dignitaries will have come to visit by train.


Stuarts Cavalry Division. I'll italicise the CSA unit names. From left to right the brigades of Hampton, Jones, Fitz Lee and Rooney. Stuart is in the tent up on the ridge. There are a couple of batteries of horse artillery as well and the entire Confederate force starts dismounted in camp and rather surprised. They are all veterans though.


Marching to the rescue late in the day is Rhodes Division with two infantry brigades. This is quite a small scale battle, each stand only represents around 1000 men but even so the number of stands is low. As a consequence both armies exhaustion points are low, so we will see how that plays out.

The Rebs are commanded by John A and played by John A (Hampton, Lee)and Tim (Jones and Rooney) with Ian joining on Wednesday (Rhodes).


Hoping to take them by surprise in a dawn attack is Pleasantons Cavalry Corps. Pleasanton (Mark) in the lead then three cavalry divisions - 1st and 2nd commanded by Russell, 3rd commanded by John B. Then we have a horse artillery battery and 1st Infantry Division, V Corps also commanded by John B.

These units are generally a bit stronger (three bases) than their CSA counterparts and have also improved in quality since 1862, but are still only rated as Seasoned. They come galloping on from the east table edge on turn one, or can wait  a turn and enter on the southeastern road.

This is a straight slogging match, to win one side must rout the other, although the Union also win a marginal victory if they manage to exhaust more CSA cavalry units at game end than Union. With such a low base density, this is going to be a very different game than the infantry heavy slogging matches. The Union breakpoint is eight bases lost, the CSA is six bases lost, rising to ten when Rhodes arrives.

OK, to battle. 


The Union opens very aggressively. 3rd Cav cross the rail bridge onto the end of the ridge, with the 1st Infantry crossing just south of there. 1st and 2nd Cavalry ride down the trail and end up athwart the railroad. General Pleasanton takes up position on a commanding hill.


The Rebs respond with some alacrity. Stuart wakes up and manages to activate Rooney who gallops east into the woods. Hampton dithers as the men gather themselves and they just mount up. Jones activates and they pivot to set up a firing line facing east, remaining dismounted. Hampton is also surprised and can just mount up and face east still in their camp.


The Union tries to take advantage of the confusion. 3rd Cavalry moves along the ridge and takes up position to cover 1st Infantry, who push up onto a hill overlooking the CSA position. The Corps artillery gallops over to join them along with Pleasanton. 1st and 2nd Cav are content to threaten the Confederate right flank.

Interesting, both sides now have a base of fire each (Jones for the CSA, 1st Infantry for the US) and the rest of their cavalry mounted. Dismounted cavalry are at a big disadvantage in melee, but uphill the threat is much reduced, and they can fire, which mounted cavalry can't.


The CSA opt to charge 3rd Cav with Hampton, covered by the horse artillery. Being veterans they need a 6 to conduct a frontal assault, and duly roll a 6. The attack is a catastrophe and easily repelled by the Union with the uphill advantage.


The following turn, 1st Infantry shoots up Hampton who loses a base, fails morale but is blocked by Johnson so loses another base. 3rd Cav charges down the hill and wipes them out. That is why veteran units don't like making frontal assaults in the Age of Rifles. That is three CSA bases lost in a turn and halfway to their rout point.


In turn Jones shoots up 3rd Cav who also lose a base and retire back up the hill. Rooney manouvres onto their open flank, no morale tests required to charge from here, so charges home but once again the uphill advantage saves 3rd Cav (in fact I rolled a bunch of 1s and 2s!) and Rooney falls back again.


Both sides suddenly discover the joys of manouvering cavalry, as they can really go a very long way indeed. Jones and 1st Infantry trade shots, Jones comes off worst, loses a base and becomes Spent. Rooney sneakily slips up onto the ridge and 3rd Cav pivot to conform. Lee now moves around the US left and 1st Cav finally stirs itself to face them but fails to charge home.

The CSA have lost four bases now to the Union one and have had two units spent or destroyed. Both sides are starting to get a feel of how to handle the numerous cavalry now, although I cant help thinking that simply getting off the horses and fighting on foot with their carbines is the way to go (as Jones is amply demonstrating).


Rooney and Lee now go on a very wide and deep outflanking manouvre on each flank, threatening numerous US units in the rear. That is a good move. Jones rallies the lost base (Veterans with JEB Stuart present, anything but a 1).


Pleasanton shrugs the CSA threat off and orders everyone forwards out of easy charge range and into an envelopment of Jones. 1st and 2nd Cav move around the left, 3rd Cav the right and 1st Infantry advances right next to Jones position.

We broke for the evening at that point, halfway through the Union turn. I'll be interested to see how the CSA respond as if the US envelopments succeeds, they could completely destroy Jones next turn and win the game.

Unfortunately both Mark and John B had to leave us at the point, but Ian was due to turn up on Wednesday so I switched him the the Union side to join Russell. 


The Rebs opted to stand so Jones fired while Rooney and Lee closed in on the Union rear. 


Russell had now taken over as overall Union commander and decided there had been enough running around and it was time for a battle of annihilation. 2nd and 3rd cavalry dismounted while 1st Cav moved to the road junction. 1st Infantry shot up Jones again and inflicted a base loss. At some personal risk Stuart tried to rally them but failed and they fell back off the ridge.


In their own turn Stuart managed to rally the base back on Jones, much to the chagrin of the US although again it was at some risk . Lee charged 1st Infantry in the rear and although losses were light (just one hit each), 1st Infantry were forced off the hill into the valley. Sadly for the CSA Rooney had chosen this moment to dither as Stuart lost sight of them.


Now it was 1st Cav turn to dither, but having dismounted the previous turn, 2nd and 3rd Cav plus the rather battered 1st Infantry poured a hail of fire into the adjacent CSA units and inflicted  a base loss on Lee. They passed their morale check but that finally took the rebels over their break point and Stuart broke off the action before Rhodes could arrive to save the day.

With that it was a well earned Union victory and hats off to Pleasanton. It was a learning experience for both sides as we've never played such a cavalry heavy ACW battle before and I think it was tempting for the players to think in Napoleonic terms, whereas these guys are essentially mounted infantry and need to be handled differently. John B commented that the rules actually captured the flavour of swirling ACW cavalry battles very well (he knows a lot more about this stuff than me) which is presumably why Neil Thomas designed them that way.

We had a good post game washup about charging and the distortion of hex grids. We've not had a game where units charged more than one hex before and the grid produced some oddities, but I think we thrashed out some possible solutions. I don't want to bog the rules down with a bunch of extra rules to cover some very specific situations, but I think I can distill it into something simple to handle units charging across the hex grid rather than along it.

Many thanks to all the players for getting to grips with that and all your helpful feedback and suggestions.








Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Spitfire vs Messerschmidt with Boom and Zoom

 I've been intrigued for a while by Joe Legans 'Boom and Zoom' tactical air combat rules. They are the polar opposite of Air War as they use area movement and a handful of dice to determine what actions each plane can take each turn.


The playing area is gridded and combat takes place within each grid area as planes vie for advantage. Here the grid is just 3 x3 but as I'm using 1/144th scale planes I made them quite big (12" squares on a 3x3 cloth).


Boom and Zoom, a very inexpensive PDF from Wargame Vault. 52 pages long and includes extensive aircraft lists, basic and advanced rules and a few (nom historical) scenarios. I printed mine out with two pages per side and bound it. As is my wont, I also made up my own QRS as I find it helps me understand the rules. There is a QRS provided with the game, but I didn't find it very helpful as it misses off some of the basic mechanisms.


Anyway, here we have a very simple aerial combat. A pair of of Bf 109F vs a pair of Spitfire Mark V somewhere over France in 1942. This is the suggested basic fighter combat scenario, but I'm ignoring wingmen as that would double the number of aircraft to push around. We've got one plane per area with random starting altitudes although three of them ended up at band 3 (low medium, about 15,000 feet), and one at band 2 (low).

I'm tracking altitude for each with a little blue D6 on the flight stand. Lets call the Spitfires Blue 1 and Blue 2 and the 109s Red 2 and Red 1 - in the order you can see them. I made a little roster up to track damage etc. I've clearly been playing Air war too much.


Flight characteristics are quite detailed with speed and agility at low, low medium, medium and high altitudes as well as firepower, defence strength, armour etc. The 109F is slightly faster than the Spitfire V at all altitudes but the Spitfire is more manouverable. They have identical firepower and defence. I didn't bother with pilot quality.

First up is initiative, a 2D6 roll for each plane, modified by various things. In this case mainly altitude, Red 1 was below all the others at altitude (A) 2 so had a penalty. After checking the dice the activation sequence was Red 2, Blue 1, Blue 2 then Red1 .


Each plane has six 'performance dice' (PD). These determine what potential actions you can take as each number corresponds to an action type. 1 = movement, 2 = manouvre 3 = situational awareness, 4 = shooting 5 = wingman (which I ignored) 6 = wildcard. 

You can play some PD to perform any action eg any dice can be played to dive or climb, but if you want to fire you have to play a 4. Some dice can be converted to others, some can be rerolled in certain circumstances etc and ideally you want to be able to play all of them to gain an advantage.

In this case Red 2 has rolled three ones (move), a two (manouvre), a three (situation) and six which can be converted to something else. At altitude 3 the 109 is slightly faster than the Spitfire, so Red 2 decides to try a high speed pass (a slashing attack) which requires 1s to execute. As the 109 is one speed faster it is allowed to convert one extra dice into a 1.


It plays 1 to fly into the opposing square. Then it converts the 2 to another 1 and plays three 1s to execute a slashing attack. The 3 can be used for a combat bonus dice and the 6 is converted 4 which is needed to actually fire.


Each 1 played up to a maximum of three affects the angle of attack, so this is an optimum attack which gains +3 combat dice. Effectively Red 2 has managed to line up a tail shot albeit at very high speed, so the advantage is only temporary.

Red 2 plays its 4 to fire and adds in the 3 (situational awareness dice) for an extra +1 dice. A Hun in the Sun perhaps.


The basic firepower of the 109F is six, with the various bonuses it throws ten D6. Of course in the excitement I made a mistake and only threw nine... 5,6 are successes so three hits.


The target throws defensive dice, and average plane throws eight along with various modifiers which didn't apply in this case. Blue1 makes five saves. If it had rolled any 1s it could have rerolled them as it is more agile than the 109. In any case, all the hits are cancelled and the attack fails. Essentially the Spitfire dodged out of the way of the 109s attack.


Red 2 doesn't have any more dice to play so remains in the square with Blue 1 and they just face off as neither has any advantage (referred to as 'neutral' in the rules). OK, now Blue 1 gets a chance to activate as it was second on the initiative roll.


Blue 1 also throws six dice and scores 1,2,4,4 and a pair of sixes. The Spitfire doesn't need to move as it is in the same square as a target, but as it s more agile than the 109 it would be best executing a 'manouvre attack' aka dogfighting. It has two 4s already so can get a shot when lined up, but only one 2 which it needs for a manouvre attack. The two sixes can also be converted to 2s though, which it does, and then declares a manouvre attack on Red 2.


To execute a manouvre attack requires an opposed roll to gain a positional advantage. The Spitfire gets a D12 and the 109 a D10, Blue 1 also plays two extra 2s (converted from sixes) to give +2. In the end it wins by six points, so gains the advantage on the 109.


Winning by six is as good as it gets, so Blue 1 ends up on the tail of the 109. This is a permanent advantage (shown by the blue chip) and the 109 will need to shake it off or the Spitfire will maintain this tail position.

Blue 1 has a 4 dice to play so shoots. Its basic firepower is six dice, with a whopping +6 for its tail position. There aren't another bonuses.


With twelve dice firing it scores four hits, pretty average, but a good shot.


Red 2 gets eight defence dice, again there aren't any bonuses. As the 109 is 'nimble' it can re-roll half its 1s, but in fact it only rolls 1. It saves two hits. So that is two hits on target. They are resolved as a single damage resolution, more hits give a bigger modifier to the damage roll.


Hit location is a D10 roll. In this case a fuel tank (ouch!). Both the Spitfires and the 109s have self sealing tanks so there is a minus damage modifier. 


Sadly Red 1 rolls a 1 on his saving throw and goes down in flames! Scratch one Bf 109.


Blue 1 still has a 1 dice left, so uses it to fly into the same square as Red 1. He still has a 4 (attack) dice too, but no speed to manouvre dice left and in any case aircraft are restricted to one attack per turn. Instead he uses it to dive down to altitude 2, which with hindsight was probably a silly move as he has then lost his initiative advantage.


Next up is Blue 2 who rolls an amazing four 2s, yes really. Just what a manouverable fighter needs. The 1 allows him to move but sadly no 4 to allow an attack.


He flies into the same area as Blue 1 and Red 1 anyway, and dives down to try an execute a manouvre attack even if he cant fire. If he can get on the 109s tail and keep the advantage, he can try for a shot next turn. He plays the useless 5 dice to dive to altitude 2. You get to reroll a dive dice. The Spitfire is a poor diver and it is lost on a 1 or 6 (engine cuts out) but in the case fortune favours the brave and he rolls a 4! 

Immediately he conducts a manouvre attack planning on using the 4 to shoot. Like the previous combat, the extra 2 dice give a +2 on the opposed dice roll, but in this case Blue 2 only wins by 2. He gets a partial tail shot (135 degrees) - players of computer flight sims will be very familiar with this in a turning fight, you just cant quite get on their tail. Anyway, it still nets a +4 attack bonus and Blue 2 opens fire.


He gets a solid hit on the cockpit, although Red 1s cockpit is armoured it doesn't stop the pilot being wounded and losing one performance dice and one level of manouverability. So Red 1 is now down to five dice and is merely average manouverability. Not great when outnumbered 2:1. His speed is unaffected however.

I tracked the damage with a couple of markers on the roster sheet although I suppose you could mark it on the planes.


Finally Red 1 gets to activate, very much paying the penalty for being bounced earlier. He needs to shake off that Spitfire on his tail. He only rolls five dice but manages to roll four 1s and a 4. Now he could try a high speed attack on Blue 1, but to shake Blue 2 from his tail he needs to try and outmanouvre him, climb away or speed away. With all those 1s and -1 manouve, manouvre is out of the question, however playing three 1s is enough to break contact.


So Red 1 opens the throttle and roars away to safety. A complete British victory in one turn! With that my head exploded and I decided to give it a rest while I reflected a bit.

Well, that was very entertaining and definitely worth a re-visit now I've got a better idea how it works. I was busily scribbling on my QRS as I went along. What a clever idea and the 'performance dice' concept I find very appealing as it reminds me of the Table Battles games we often play which also use six decision dice. The hardest thing is understanding the options for each dice hand, and there is a certain degree of looking up what various aircraft traits mean - partly why I avoided Spitfire I and Bf 109E as both have a lot of idiosyncroses wrt climbing and diving. 

That engagement took me about an 40 minutes to play but it would be much faster once you get more familiar with how things hang together. I complete ignored the stuff abut wingmen which run on AI but I might introduce those at a later date. If I had any criticisms about the rules, it is that they read more like a long essay with attached notes than a set of rules, but they do have lots of play examples. I was also a bit disappointed with the aircraft selection as it misses out quite a few I'm interested in (later marks of Spitfire, Tempests, Jets) but is pretty comprehensive for early war, the Pacific and eastern front. I'll definitely be doing some more of this so in future though.

If you are interesting in finding out more, Joe has some play examples on his blog which cover rather bigger battles than this one  and give you an idea how it hangs together. Have a look at February and July 2026 in particular.


I subsequently had a bit of correspondence with Joe and he has already published a revised version of the rules on Wargames vault with some clarifications and updated aircraft stats. He is also planning on adding more aircraft, particularly British, later this year. Version 2 of the rules now on Wargames Vault tidies up and clarifies some things. 


Friday, 13 November 2026

Irish Freedom by White Dog Games

 Jim wanted to try out another solo game as a team effort, this time 'Irish Freedom' by White Dog Games. BGG entry here: https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/360480/irish-freedom As a solo game the player is the Irish fighting for independence against the British forces of oppression including the infamous Black and Tans. The scenarios cover both the War of Independence and the Civil War, which can either be played as standalone scenarios or combined into one longer campaign.


The map is a stylised area movement map with six major regions joined by roads. Each of the regions is subdivided into four areas with one of three terrain types - 'bog', town land or city. eg Dublin is a city, whereas most of Kerry is bog! This matters as each type of unit has a different combat rating in different types of terrain.

The aim of the game is to force the British to sign the Treaty within ten turns. At the start of each turn there is 'Treaty test', comparing a dice throw against the number of regions occupied by at least one British unit, the number of cities not occupied by an Irish unit minus the number of eliminated British units. So the idea is to occupy enough ground and inflict enough losses to force the British to negotiate.


We had a fair turnout for this one, myself, Mark and Russell were the rebels, John A and John B the British and their chums in the Royal Irish Constabulary. In the standard game the British are system controlled, whereas playing this as an opposed game Jim let the British make various tactical decisions.


A slightly different view of the map with more detail - you can better make out the different terrain types. There are also various hieroglyphs to do with unit recruitment, and some of the cities are marked as ports. Port of Dublin was vital as that is where British reinforcements arrived.

I was Tom Barry, in charge of Kerry and Cork.


Russell had the West and Midlands. As you might expect Ulster and Dublin were centres of British force. Mark was Micheal Collins himself, and could activate two regions a turn to do something.


The starting setup in 1919. Apologies for the blurry images. The red units are various types of 'British', in ascending order of combat power, RIC, Black and Tans, Army. The police and Tans were generally more effective in towns and cities.

The green and blue units are IRA (the green/blue distinction matters more in the Civil War scenario). Their units in ascending order of power were mobs, guerillas and flying columns. Generally they were best in bogland and worst in cities. Flying columns can move between cities along the roads.


The first couple of turns were spent by the British consolidating their hold on Ulster and Dublin, crushing the mobs in Dublin. We built up our forces in the rest of the country but they kept get battered by superior forces. On an activation you can 'recruit' a unit - in the case of the IRA a new guerilla, or you can upgrade an existing unit to the next level, mob to guerilla to flying column.

Then you can make a move from one area to another, and if you end up in the same area as an enemy unit, fight a battle, which is a simple CRT modified by the difference in combat strength. You can stack a maximum of two friendly units together. So while there are a lot of units on the map, not many of them move in a single turn.


The British started pushing units into the Midlands, but we had been steadily recruiting and upgrading out units in the south and west and finally had some military success against the Tans (two eliminated units in the big red box). The only way to beat the better British units was by stacking and picking where to fight in favourable terrain.


With a number of units now upgraded to Flying Columns, we even managed to take the fight to Dublin. One column took the bogland outside the city, but the British had rather unwisely left the port ungarrisoned so another unit occupied it, cutting off their flow of reinforcements next turn.

Exciting stuff and a good point to end for the night. Totting up the Treaty Points we had now got the British down to five, so on a six, they would sit down and negotiate. I don't imagine our hold on Dublin will last as most of our units only have a combat value of 1 in a city while the British Army is worth (4!), but we can hope...

With sides a bit stronger there was a fair bit going on and inexplicably I didn't take any photos!


Briefly, we got kicked out of Dublin but instead gained a foothold in Ulster which provoked a very strong response. The British had a go at Kerry and Cork which proved to be a mistake as a failed Tans attack left Cork itself ungarrisoned, and while British Army units rampaged around and even took control of the region, eventually Tom Barry's flying column headed south and ambushed them in bogland in northwest Kerry.

The battle resulted in complete defeat for the British and as we rolled into turn seven, there were five British units in the eliminated box and IRA units occupied North Dublin, Cork city and the whole of Kerry.  This reduced the Treaty Score to three, and we duly rolled a four. The war was over and Britain agreed to peace and an Irish Free State. Hurrah!

That took six turns/noths and was worth 3 VP (faster times generate higher scores). I think that was fairly average. Anyway, it was a very intriguing game - interesting to play and informative too. The limited actions each turn avoided the whole turning into a blood bath and meant there were hard decisions  to make each turn which actually impacted the outcomes and it wasn't overly random.

I think having the British played by people instead of the game system probably meant they took better decisions, hence the Army magically ending up in southwest Ireland in no time at all. Jim had added some extra things like automatic reinforcements of reach side each turn, which I'm not convinced about as it increased the unit count and induced some odd behaviours eg the British were encouraged to leave Dublin empty to fit another seaborne Army unit in, but of course it also left it wide open to IRA occupation.

Anyway, it was a good game and I'll look forward to playing the Irish Civil War although it has a hefty UK price tag Being an import (£50 plus) so I don't think I'll be rushing out to buy it.