I've been intrigued for a while by Joe Legans 'Boom and Zoom' tactical air combat rules. They are the polar opposite of Air War as they use area movement and a handful of dice to determine what actions each plane can take each turn.
The playing area is gridded and combat takes place within each grid area as planes vie for advantage. Here the grid is just 3 x3 but as I'm using 1/144th scale planes I made them quite big (12" squares on a 3x3 cloth).
Boom and Zoom, a very inexpensive PDF from Wargame Vault. 52 pages long and includes extensive aircraft lists, basic and advanced rules and a few (nom historical) scenarios. I printed mine out with two pages per side and bound it. As is my wont, I also made up my own QRS as I find it helps me understand the rules. There is a QRS provided with the game, but I didn't find it very helpful as it misses off some of the basic mechanisms.
Anyway, here we have a very simple aerial combat. A pair of of Bf 109F vs a pair of Spitfire Mark V somewhere over France in 1942. This is the suggested basic fighter combat scenario, but I'm ignoring wingmen as that would double the number of aircraft to push around. We've got one plane per area with random starting altitudes although three of them ended up at band 3 (low medium, about 15,000 feet), and one at band 2 (low).
I'm tracking altitude for each with a little blue D6 on the flight stand. Lets call the Spitfires Blue 1 and Blue 2 and the 109s Red 2 and Red 1 - in the order you can see them. I made a little roster up to track damage etc. I've clearly been playing Air war too much.
Flight characteristics are quite detailed with speed and agility at low, low medium, medium and high altitudes as well as firepower, defence strength, armour etc. The 109F is slightly faster than the Spitfire V at all altitudes but the Spitfire is more manouverable. They have identical firepower and defence. I didn't bother with pilot quality.
First up is initiative, a 2D6 roll for each plane, modified by various things. In this case mainly altitude, Red 1 was below all the others at altitude (A) 2 so had a penalty. After checking the dice the activation sequence was Red 2, Blue 1, Blue 2 then Red1 .
Each plane has six 'performance dice' (PD). These determine what potential actions you can take as each number corresponds to an action type. 1 = movement, 2 = manouvre 3 = situational awareness, 4 = shooting 5 = wingman (which I ignored) 6 = wildcard.
You can play some PD to perform any action eg any dice can be played to dive or climb, but if you want to fire you have to play a 4. Some dice can be converted to others, some can be rerolled in certain circumstances etc and ideally you want to be able to play all of them to gain an advantage.
In this case Red 2 has rolled three ones (move), a two (manouvre), a three (situation) and six which can be converted to something else. At altitude 3 the 109 is slightly faster than the Spitfire, so Red 2 decides to try a high speed pass (a slashing attack) which requires 1s to execute. As the 109 is one speed faster it is allowed to convert one extra dice into a 1.
It plays 1 to fly into the opposing square. Then it converts the 2 to another 1 and plays three 1s to execute a slashing attack. The 3 can be used for a combat bonus dice and the 6 is converted 4 which is needed to actually fire.
Each 1 played up to a maximum of three affects the angle of attack, so this is an optimum attack which gains +3 combat dice. Effectively Red 2 has managed to line up a tail shot albeit at very high speed, so the advantage is only temporary.
Red 2 plays its 4 to fire and adds in the 3 (situational awareness dice) for an extra +1 dice. A Hun in the Sun perhaps.
The basic firepower of the 109F is six, with the various bonuses it throws ten D6. Of course in the excitement I made a mistake and only threw nine... 5,6 are successes so three hits.
The target throws defensive dice, and average plane throws eight along with various modifiers which didn't apply in this case. Blue1 makes five saves. If it had rolled any 1s it could have rerolled them as it is more agile than the 109. In any case, all the hits are cancelled and the attack fails. Essentially the Spitfire dodged out of the way of the 109s attack.
Red 2 doesn't have any more dice to play so remains in the square with Blue 1 and they just face off as neither has any advantage (referred to as 'neutral' in the rules). OK, now Blue 1 gets a chance to activate as it was second on the initiative roll.
Blue 1 also throws six dice and scores 1,2,4,4 and a pair of sixes. The Spitfire doesn't need to move as it is in the same square as a target, but as it s more agile than the 109 it would be best executing a 'manouvre attack' aka dogfighting. It has two 4s already so can get a shot when lined up, but only one 2 which it needs for a manouvre attack. The two sixes can also be converted to 2s though, which it does, and then declares a manouvre attack on Red 2.
To execute a manouvre attack requires an opposed roll to gain a positional advantage. The Spitfire gets a D12 and the 109 a D10, Blue 1 also plays two extra 2s (converted from sixes) to give +2. In the end it wins by six points, so gains the advantage on the 109.
Winning by six is as good as it gets, so Blue 1 ends up on the tail of the 109. This is a permanent advantage (shown by the blue chip) and the 109 will need to shake it off or the Spitfire will maintain this tail position.
Blue 1 has a 4 dice to play so shoots. Its basic firepower is six dice, with a whopping +6 for its tail position. There aren't another bonuses.
With twelve dice firing it scores four hits, pretty average, but a good shot.
Red 2 gets eight defence dice, again there aren't any bonuses. As the 109 is 'nimble' it can re-roll half its 1s, but in fact it only rolls 1. It saves two hits. So that is two hits on target. They are resolved as a single damage resolution, more hits give a bigger modifier to the damage roll.
Hit location is a D10 roll. In this case a fuel tank (ouch!). Both the Spitfires and the 109s have self sealing tanks so there is a minus damage modifier.
Sadly Red 1 rolls a 1 on his saving throw and goes down in flames! Scratch one Bf 109.
Blue 1 still has a 1 dice left, so uses it to fly into the same square as Red 1. He still has a 4 (attack) dice too, but no speed to manouvre dice left and in any case aircraft are restricted to one attack per turn. Instead he uses it to dive down to altitude 2, which with hindsight was probably a silly move as he has then lost his initiative advantage.
Next up is Blue 2 who rolls an amazing four 2s, yes really. Just what a manouverable fighter needs. The 1 allows him to move but sadly no 4 to allow an attack.
He flies into the same area as Blue 1 and Red 1 anyway, and dives down to try an execute a manouvre attack even if he cant fire. If he can get on the 109s tail and keep the advantage, he can try for a shot next turn. He plays the useless 5 dice to dive to altitude 2. You get to reroll a dive dice. The Spitfire is a poor diver and it is lost on a 1 or 6 (engine cuts out) but in the case fortune favours the brave and he rolls a 4!
Immediately he conducts a manouvre attack planning on using the 4 to shoot. Like the previous combat, the extra 2 dice give a +2 on the opposed dice roll, but in this case Blue 2 only wins by 2. He gets a partial tail shot (135 degrees) - players of computer flight sims will be very familiar with this in a turning fight, you just cant quite get on their tail. Anyway, it still nets a +4 attack bonus and Blue 2 opens fire.
He gets a solid hit on the cockpit, although Red 1s cockpit is armoured it doesn't stop the pilot being wounded and losing one performance dice and one level of manouverability. So Red 1 is now down to five dice and is merely average manouverability. Not great when outnumbered 2:1. His speed is unaffected however.
I tracked the damage with a couple of markers on the roster sheet although I suppose you could mark it on the planes.
Finally Red 1 gets to activate, very much paying the penalty for being bounced earlier. He needs to shake off that Spitfire on his tail. He only rolls five dice but manages to roll four 1s and a 4. Now he could try a high speed attack on Blue 1, but to shake Blue 2 from his tail he needs to try and outmanouvre him, climb away or speed away. With all those 1s and -1 manouve, manouvre is out of the question, however playing three 1s is enough to break contact.
So Red 1 opens the throttle and roars away to safety. A complete British victory in one turn! With that my head exploded and I decided to give it a rest while I reflected a bit.
Well, that was very entertaining and definitely worth a re-visit now I've got a better idea how it works. I was busily scribbling on my QRS as I went along. What a clever idea and the 'performance dice' concept I find very appealing as it reminds me of the Table Battles games we often play which also use six decision dice. The hardest thing is understanding the options for each dice hand, and there is a certain degree of looking up what various aircraft traits mean - partly why I avoided Spitfire I and Bf 109E as both have a lot of idiosyncroses wrt climbing and diving.
That engagement took me about an 40 minutes to play but it would be much faster once you get more familiar with how things hang together. I complete ignored the stuff abut wingmen which run on AI but I might introduce those at a later date. If I had any criticisms about the rules, it is that they read more like a long essay with attached notes than a set of rules, but they do have lots of play examples. I was also a bit disappointed with the aircraft selection as it misses out quite a few I'm interested in (later marks of Spitfire, Tempests, Jets) but is pretty comprehensive for early war, the Pacific and eastern front. I'll definitely be doing some more of this so in future though.
If you are interesting in finding out more, Joe has some play examples on his blog which cover rather bigger battles than this one and give you an idea how it hangs together. Have a look at February and July 2026 in particular.
I subsequently had a bit of correspondence with Joe and he has already published a revised version of the rules on Wargames vault with some clarifications and updated aircraft stats. He is also planning on adding more aircraft, particularly British, later this year. Version 2 of the rules now on Wargames Vault tidies up and clarifies some things.
























No comments:
Post a Comment